Pun-tastic Kashmir
I knew a guy whose name was Joshua, known to one and all simply as Josh. Online his nickname was Rogan. Just that. And it was only the desis (and to some extent the limeys) who got the wonderful pun: Rogan Josh! I still happen to think that's the smartest online name I have ever seen, but then I'm funny that way.
Sra from When my Soup came Alive posted a recipe she'd found in a cookbook for Vegetarian Rogan Josh. And so in honor of that pun, I decided to try it.
Now, this is one recipe where we just couldn't manage to follow the instructions - or even the ingredients. We tweaked it so much, I doubt it could even be called the same dish, so go on over to Sra's blog and check out the original recipe at the link above.
It starts with the fact that we didn't have red pumpkin on hand; we did however have bottle gourd, and given the fact that they are all part of the same extended family, we swapped that in.
Next came the fact of the proportions of the spices: we had to lessen the chilli powder or Angel Face won't eat it, reduce the percentage of aniseed powder since the flavor is pretty dominant, and substitute powdered asafoetida for asafoetida water. And as a final deviation, we substantially increased the amount of yoghurt.
What can I say? Sometimes the inner tweaker just takes over. And it was delicious. The yoghurt really separates with the oil rimming the edges. Depending on your preference you can stir it back into the dish before serving, or try and serve the pieces while catching as little oil as possible. Remember though that the oil serves as a vehicle to disperse the spices, so a lot of the flavor of the dish is in there.
The accompaniment for this is obvious: Kashmiri pulao of course. What was that? You don't have a recipe for that? Oh my goodness, I just might have to scratch around a bit and see if I can dig up mine again...

Comments (5)
Sivani, just saw your comment on my blog.
Looks like yours turned into a totally different dish altogether! There's a recipe in the same book for Bottlegourd Rogan Josh as well!
And you know what I noticed about fennel? You think it would be a dominant taste, but it really isn't once it's been doused in oil, I don't use it much so it was awakening - I used it for the pumpkin and later for a Chettinad chicken dish - quite mild, to my surprise.
Posted by sra | October 27, 2007 12:05 PM
I remember sra's dish, but your's has turned out to be equally lovely.
Posted by sunita | October 27, 2007 2:56 PM
That is a cute online name. This looks so good.. love the colour of the dish.
Posted by Laavanya | October 27, 2007 3:05 PM
The spice mixture is so unique. Do kashmiri dishes use a lot of curd? Most of the recipes I have come across have a milk product.
Posted by Suganya | October 28, 2007 10:33 AM
@Sra: Interesting tip; I'll keep it mind for next time. I did however use aniseed as opposed to fennel, which might account for the difference in flavor.
@Sunita: You are very gracious in your praise :-)
@Laavanya: I keep kicking myself because I could never come up with anything as satisfyingly sharp as that.
@Suganya: They seem to be uniformly rich and decadent. Oh, and utterly delicious!
Posted by Sivani
|
November 1, 2007 3:29 PM